a blue and orange check mark with the letter w on it as the Wilson Whitaker Rynell Logo

Examples of Design Patent Infringement

John Wilson • April 17, 2019

Examples of Design Patent Infringement

a large light bulb is hanging from the ceiling in a room .

Given the prior art it can often be difficult to tell if a viable claim for design patent infringement can be maintained against manufacturers of similar products.


Test For Design Patent Infringement


The primary test for determining infringement of a design patent was established in the seminal design patent infringement case, Gorham Co. v. White, 81 U.S. 511 (1871). In Gorham, the United States Supreme Court declared that infringement of a design patent occurs if: “in the eye of an ordinary observer, giving such attention as a purchaser usually gives, two designs are substantially the same.” In 2008, a Federal Circuit court held that the “ordinary observer test,” as established in Gorham, is the sole test for determining design patent infringement; however, the determination must be “conducted in light of the prior art.” If a design patent is substantially similar to prior art, then the differences between the design patent and the potentially-infringing products will be accentuated. Therefore, the appropriate test for design patent infringement is whether an ordinary observer would consider two designs substantially the same, considering the prior art.


Design patent infringement is highly contingent on prior art. Therefore, the relevant prior art must be considered when analyzing the viability of claims against potential infringers. 35 U.S.C. §102(b) identifies that prior art may consist of an invention that “was patented or described in a printed publication in this or a foreign country or in public use or on sale in this country, more than one year prior to the date of application for patent in the United States.”   


Examples of Design Patent Infringement


Although design patent infringement is determined on a case-by-case basis, examples of prior decisions may be used as a guideline to predict potential outcomes of future design patent infringement cases. The following examples used the “ordinary observer” test to determine that a design patent had been infringed. 


The Federal Circuit court in a Crocs case entered a judgment of infringement against ITC noting that a “side-by-side comparisons of the…products suggest that an ordinary observer, familiar with the prior art designs, would be deceived into believing the accused products are the same as the patented design” Specifically, the Federal Circuit court explained that “minor differences between a patented design and an accused article’s design cannot, and shall not, prevent a finding of infringement.” The figure below displays a side-by-side comparison of the two products at issue in the case.

a black and white drawing of a crocs shoe
Crocs v. ITC, 598 F.3d 1294 (Fed. Cir. 2010)

The Federal District Court of Maryland in Victor Stanley held that the manufacturers of a park bench infringed upon a prior design patent because “an ordinary observer, familiar with prior art designs, would be unable to easily distinguish them in a side-by-side comparison without unusually careful effort.” The figure below displays a side-by-side comparison of the products.  Although the prior art in Victor Stanley featured a looped arm rest and curved bench legs, both the ‘623 patent and the infringing design featured accentuated curvature of the legs, which was the distinguishing feature of the ‘623 patent and the prior art.  
a drawing of a bench and a picture of a bench
Victor Stanley v. Creative Pipe, 2011 LEXIS 112846 (D.Md. 2011)
Person sitting cross-legged against a doodle-covered wall, holding up a sign with a light bulb drawing.
By John Wilson • November 21, 2026
Business owners facing divorce in Dallas or Texas must protect patents, trademarks, and trade secrets. Learn characterization, valuation, and strategies under Texas community property law.
Large white “HOME” letters stand on a wooden shelf outdoors against a sunlit, leafy background.
By John Wilson • November 18, 2026
House owned before marriage in a Texas divorce: ownership, principal, interest, and appreciation rules under Texas Family Code § 3.402. Key case law on reimbursement claims explained by Dallas family law attorneys.
Wooden letter tiles spelling “DO NOT COPY” arranged in three rows on a textured surface.
By Leigh Whitaker • November 17, 2026
Learn why copying content that contains your trademark is usually not trademark infringement under the Lanham Act. Key lessons from Dastar and the Slep-Tone karaoke case on the meaning of “origin of goods.”
Chanel No. 5 perfume bottle surrounded by white roses on a light surface
By Jennifer Rynell • November 10, 2026
When can a product use “inspired by” or compare itself to a competitor’s brand? Wilson Whitaker Rynell analyzes key Lanham Act cases on comparative advertising and product packaging
Marketing Strategy booklet on a desk with a white cover and dark text
By John Wilson • November 9, 2026
Learn why advertising and preparatory activities often fail to qualify as trademark “use in commerce” for service marks under USPTO rules, including key lessons from U.S. legal cases.
Gold scales of justice on a desk, with a blurred person holding papers in an office background
By Samantha Delgado • November 6, 2026
Learn how non-U.S. residents can probate a foreign will in Texas through ancillary probate under the Texas Estates Code. Covers authentication, resident agents under § 304.003, independent administration, and the step-by-step process.
Text “CHOICES” in raised tan letters on a textured beige wall.
By Kayla Holderman • October 30, 2026
Learn whether a pre-existing choice-of-law clause remains enforceable after converting an out-of-state entity to a Texas LLC under the TBOC.
2026 Texas Super Lawyers and Rising Stars ad for Wilson Whitaker Rynell, with four attorney headshots
By John Wilson • October 27, 2026
Wilson Whitaker Rynell attorneys named to the 2026 Texas Super Lawyers and Rising Stars lists. Learn about the honors and the firm’s work in IP, business litigation, and family law.
Blurred person in a yellow raincoat riding a scooter through a rainy street scene
By Samantha Delgado • October 27, 2026
Acceleration clauses in Texas promissory notes: learn when they are enforceable, the required notices under Texas law, statute of limitations issues, and how to avoid common mistakes.
Show More
The Wilson Legal Group are Dallas attorneys that specializes in Patents, Trademarks, Copyrights, Trade Secrets, Complex Litigation, Business/Corporate Law, Family Law and Real Estate Law. At the Wilson Legal Group, our clients are our focus. Our philosophy is simple and straight-forward: Understand our clients' needs, hopes, and interests in order to help them flourish. Our staff strives to build strong relationships with our clients in order to appreciate their best interests and help them achieve their goals.

Request A Blog?

Have an idea for a blog?  Click and request a blog and we will let you know when we post it!